Denise Feeley is an avid runner and Registered Dietitian with
more than eight years of experience counseling athletes. She is
currently an adjunct professor in the Department of Exercise
Science at George Washington University. She is available for
nutrition counseling. For information or questions contact her
at denf44@yahoo.com.
The nutrition supplement industry is a multi-billion dollar
industry. About half of American adults take nutrition
supplements on a daily basis. The percentage of athletes using
supplements is even higher. Unlike over-the-counter and
prescription medications, the Food and Drug Administration or
any other regulatory agency does not regulate supplements.
The "regulation" of dietary supplements falls under the Dietary
Supplement Health and Education Act (DSHEA) passed in 1994. This
legislation is ambiguous at best and in fact there are entire
books written on the interpretation of this act.
In summary, dietary supplements do not need to be proven safe
and effective before they are marketed and sold, unlike
medications. The manufacturer is responsible for ensuring that
its supplements are safe before they are packaged and marketed.
The manufacturer is not required to disclose safety or efficacy
information to the FDA or to the consumer before a supplement is
marketed; each company is responsible for formulating its own
policy. However, a consumer can request this information from
the manufacturer if desired.
A potential loophole in this legislation is that thorough and
scientific clinical trials are not required and thus many of
the "studies" done by the companies are not considered
scientific nor are the results statistically significant. The
companies are also not required to record, investigate, or
forward to the FDA any reports of adverse side effects,
illnesses, or injuries that may have occurred as a result of the
ingestion of the supplement. However, consumers are encouraged
to report any side effects, illnesses, or deaths to the FDA.
Under DSHEA, the FDA is required to investigate such reports and
determine whether the supplement is "unsafe" before it can be
removed from the market.
At this time, the dietary supplement ephedra, which is found in
certain weight loss supplements, has been associated with
several deaths and is under investigation by the FDA. Kava-
containing supplements (usually marketed as a treatment for
anxiety) are also under investigation due to its association
with liver failure in individuals ingesting the supplement.
Nutrition supplement labels are required to display
a "supplement facts" label, which contains a list of each
dietary ingredient contained in the label. Food products are
required to list the serving size whereas nutrition supplements
are not. The amount of the "nutrient" contained in the
supplement is not restricted either, so there are no consistent
amounts of a "nutrient" found between different manufacturers.
For example, if you were to examine several different nutrition
supplements that contained creatine, none of them would contain
the same amount nor would they necessarily contain the same form
of creatine.
As a health care professional, I will only make recommendations
based on what is reported in the literature. You can probably
surmise that I am not an advocate of nutrition supplements
unless it has been proven scientifically to exude a benefit with
minimal, if any, side effects. If you are regularly taking a
supplement with a hypothetical benefit, thoroughly research the
supplement to see if there are any published studies on the use
of the supplement. If you experience any usual side effects,
report them to your physician.