There are signs in research papers and some recent diet books
that a new approach to healthy eating will meet your needs if
you are concerned about weight control. The principle is: count
fat grams, not calories. Since new food labels are in use, it is
now easier to track fat, and if you eat a variety of foods the
calories can take care of themselves.Why does it work?
There is ample evidence that the main source of stored body fat
is fat from your diet. In that case the first step to prevent
excess fat storage is to eat less fat.
It is easy to eat too much fat. Many foods you love contain
loads of fat, and are high in calories: cheeseburgers, hot dogs,
pizza with all the trimmings, ice cream, potato chips, and more.
If you find it easy to eat more fat than your body needs, then
you need to count grams of fat.
It is hard to eat too much high carbohydrate food. Why? Because
carbohydrate foods usually contain plenty of water, have a low
density, and therefore are very bulky, and are lower in calories
than fatty foods (four calories a gram from carbohydrate, nine
calories a gram from fat). A normal appetite will control your
total calorie intake as long as you eat high carbohydrate low
fat. In other words, if you take care of your grams of fat, your
appetite will take care of your total calories. We don't say you
can pig out on carbohydrate foods just because they're okay. We
say if you eat reasonably and keep down your fat intake, you can
settle to your natural bodyweight and not be hungry from calorie
restriction.
But, you may ask, if I don't track calories and eat as much
carbohydrate as I like,suppose I eat too much carbohydrate? As
we said, normally you can't eat too many carbohydrate calories
because you won't have the capacity. But even if you did it
wouldn't matter. If you've heard and read that excess
carbohydrate can be turned into fat. Well, it can, but only
under very unusual conditions that are miles away from
reasonable eating.
Here are the well-documented facts about excess carbohydrate. If
you eat more carbohydrate than usual, the first thing that
happens is your carbohydrate store increases. This, after all,
is the principle of carbohydrate loading, and folks don't get
fat on carbo loading. Suppose you have a super-human appetite
and you eat more even though your muscles and liver are chock-
full of stored carbohydrate, what then? The answer is the rate
at which your body burns carbohydrate increases. Only a tiny
amount is turned into fat. A series of studies measured
conversion of carbohydrate to fat when people ate large amounts
of carbohydrate. As much as 2,000 calories of carbohydrate
yielded not more than 9 grams of body fat, that's less than 2%
of the weight of the large amount of carbs.
Researchers were curious to see if they could force people to
turn carbohydrate into fat and store it like hibernating bears.
Well they did, but only by massive overfeeding and cutting their
fat intake to 3% total calories.
If your body is getting enough fat to supply its needs for
essential fat tissues, then it is satisfied and doesn't need to
turn carbohydrate into fat, so it doesn't except to a very small
extent, and only after it has increased carbohydrate stores and
increased the rate of burning the stuff as much as possible. If
your body is being starved of fat and is not getting enough then
it will begin to convert carbohydrate to meet its needs, but it
takes very large amounts of carbohydrate, because the conversion
is a long, inefficient process.
The bottom line is that given good health, a normal metabolism
and appetite, if you limit fat, you don't need to count
calories. There have been a couple of studies on controlled low
fat, but unrestricted calorie diets. The total calories
automatically stayed in a reasonable range to provide energy,
and folks who were overweight slowly lost some.
How much fat?
We will take the guidelines for athletes proposed by the
American and Canadian Dietetic Associations and make the
calculations for you.
For a 115 pound women with a sedentary job, running 20 miles a
week, her calorie needs are about 2,000 per day. With 20% to 25%
from fat, the range of fat intake should be 45 to 55 grams per
day. If you are a heavier women you can increase this in
proportion to your bodyweight. If you run more than 20 miles a
week, or are more active at work, eat more carbohydrate, not
more fat
A 150 pound man with a sedentary job, running 20 miles a week,
needs about 2,700 calories a day, with 60 to 75 grams of fat per
day. You can scale up the fat if you are heavier, but for a more
active job or more exercise push up the carbs, not fat. An even
simpler way to tailor your fat needs to your bodyweight is to
convert your weight to kilograms (pounds x 0.454 = kilograms).
This number matches your suggested daily fat intake in grams,
says Editorial Board Member Jack Daniels, Ph.D.
We've put in the calories to let you see where the fat estimates
came from, but now you can forget them and concentrate only on
fat grams.
Where's the fat?
To achieve low fat intake you don't have to avoid fat foods, but
you have to take care how you combine portions. If you eat a 3.5
ounce T-bone steak with 25 grams of fat and eat a salad with
tablespoon of regular dressing with nine grams of fat, that may
be more than half your daily target. That's okay, but it means
that you may have to avoid a cheese or ham sandwich snack that
could add up to 20 grams more of fat, unless you're an over-
average heavy woman or a man.
It is good to eat meats, poultry, and seafood, they contain
essential nutrients such as iron and zinc, but you must control
the amount. You simply cannot afford to tackle one of the huge
steaks showcased by some restaurants. The right serving of
meats, poultry, and seafood is three to four ounces. If you are
served anything larger than a deck of cards, cut it down to size
and take the rest home. A restaurant meal of meat, classic sauce
such as bearnaise, salad with house dressing, is going to give
you about 60 grams of fat. That's over the top for most women,
and gets into the daily range for many men. It's okay to eat
that meal, but you've got to cut out any fat in breakfast, lunch
and snacks.
Similarly, if you get into a fast food group for lunch and feel
the temptation of a Big Mac (35 grams of fat) and regular fries
(11.5 grams of fat), you can have them. But you'd better have
pasta and a regular vegetable-tomato sauce for dinner, not meat,
sauce, and salad with dressing.
You can widen your choices by switching to nonfat and low-fat
choices for many foods. For dairy products this is relatively
easy. Try skim and low-fat milk, nonfat or low-fat ice cream,
cheese, and yogurt. They taste different at first but your
palate will adjust. After six months, or maybe longer for some
people, they will taste good, and you won't miss the creamy
taste of the higher fat varieties (in fact, you may no longer
like them). There are also many prepared foods in low-fat
versions, such as dressings and sauces. Learn to enjoy them.
You can slowly (quick changes in diet may upset your stomach and
lower intestine) learn to eat as many fruits and vegetables as
you like. They provide plenty of vitamins and minerals, are
bulky to satisfy your appetite, and are relatively low in
calories. Best of all, you can forget their fat content (except
avocado and olives: these pack in fat).
Breads, cereals, pasta or noodles, and prepared grain products
are relatively low in fat, but you need to check the labels
because fat grams add up. A slice of whole wheat bread sounds
innocuous with one gram of fat. But if you eat three sandwiches,
the total of six grams of fat from the bread is significant.
It's easy to keep fat down at breakfast. Cereal and skim milk
with fruit, toast and preserves, juice, and coffee with skim
milk are filling, and keep fat to not more than three grams of
fat.
Lunch on fruits, whole grain bread, and soup is bulky and
nutritious, and you can hold fat to seven grams.
With meat, poultry, and seafood portions of three to four
ounces, fat is variable but can usually be kept to about 25
grams. Check sauces carefully or make nonfat versions from wine
and herbs. You can eat vegetables without restriction. Enliven
your palate with a variety; it is much more interesting to pop
half a dozen veggies into a steamer, rather than a larger amount
of one or two.
Make salad an important part of your meal plan. Use your
imagination to use the largest possible variety of ingredients;
not only vegetables, but pasta and fruits can add to your
enjoyment. In fact, with a large enough variety you may not need
a dressing, or at least can cut it to a tablespoon of olive oil
(13.5 grams of fat) and vinegar or lemon juice with herbs.
Many people who eat breakfast, a large lunch and a large dinner,
as in the European tradition find less need for snacks. If you
begin to switch to limiting your fat intake to the guidelines
suggested here and allow yourself unlimited carbohydrate, snacks
will be less of a problem except when faced with unusually high
energy demands for long endurance workouts. When this happens
you will need to avoid many traditional American snack foods,
such as chips and dips, and hot dogs. Instead concentrate on
breads and bagels, nonfat yogurt, fruits or vegetables and
juices, and don't forget energy bars, and high carbohydrate
sports drinks.
If you count grams of fat, and gradually switch to a high,
unrestricted carbohydrate diet, you should get plenty of energy
for your activities and workouts, and your weight and body fat
should settle to where your genes want them. If you try it for a
while and it doesn't seem to work as expected (bearing in mind
George Sheehan's "Every patient is an experiment of one"), check
with a registered dietitian to help you count fat grams.