Even though the experts say most Americas are obsessed with
being thin, if you look around you'll see that most Americans
are overweight. In fact, over one third of the adult U.S.
population is obese--that's a 10% increase from the number of
people who were obese in 1980. And the number continues to
climb.
So how do we reduce our nation's fat, and your waist
line? Exercise is certainly a sure-
fire way to fight the bulge. But if you don't eat a low-fat diet
in conjunction with your regular exercise program you may be
fighting a losing battle.
Many health professionals say you have to go on a low-
calorie diet. They say "A calorie is a calorie is a calorie"
and "All excess calories will be stored as fat." Be cautious of
these warnings. They are only half-truths, and are not the main
issue when dealing with weight control. You do not eat calories,
you eat carbohydrate, fat, and protein. And each of these are
used and stored differently by the body.
What is a Calorie?
A kilocalorie, or what we commonly refer to as a calorie, is a
measure of heat energy. It represents the amount of heat needed
to raise the temperature of one kilogram of water (slightly more
than a quart) by one degree Celsius. For example, a can of
chicken noodle soup with 90 calories per serving has enough
chemical energy in one serving to raise the temperature of 90
quarts of water by one degree Celsius. But if the can of soup is
actually chemical energy that produces heat, what happens when
you eat it?
Where Does It All Go?
The protein in the soup (coming mostly from the chicken), which
equals four calories per gram, is broken down and then
reassembled to replace protein in your body lost by routine cell
turnover, especially in the muscles. Some protein is also used
to make enzymes and other key chemicals needed to make your
metabolism work.
Suppose you add up all the protein in your daily diet, and it
comes to more than your body needs. What happens? The calorie
counters say it's turned into fat. "But this would call for some
monumental biochemical processes, and there is no evidence in
the scientific literature to support this," reports Trevor
Smith, a retired research chemist and editor of Running &
FitNews. The fact is that extra protein is oxidized, which means
it is burned off and converted to compounds that are eliminated
from the body.
What happens to the fat in your soup, and other foods you eat?
Some replaces lost tissues such as cell membranes and certain
cells in your nervous system. The rest is used for energy in
your body. Fat is a very high-energy source, providing nine
calories per gram, and if you eat more fat than your body needs
during the day, the rest is stored for later use. The trouble
with this is that the body's capacity to store fat seems
limitless.
People who eat more fat than they can burn keep storing the
stuff day after day. And they get fatter and fatter. The fate of
the carbohydrate in your soup (coming from the vegetables and
pasta), and in the rest of your daily foods, is more
interesting. A little carbohydrate is used in cell turnover but
the majority is used for energy.
Although it produces only four calories per gram, when
carbohydrate is the main part of your daily diet you have plenty
of energy. What if you eat too much carbohydrate? The calorie
counters say it's turned into fat. However, the scientific
literature tells a different story. "First, some extra
carbohydrate can be stored as glycogen, which is the breakdown
product of carbohydrate. Normally you store glycogen in your
muscles, with a smaller amount in your liver," says Susan
Kalish, executive director of the American Medical Athletic
Association. "The muscle store of glycogen can increase, which
is the principle of carbo loading. If you use up muscle
glycogen, say with a long, exhausting run, and then quickly
begin replacing it by eating high carbohydrate foods (bananas,
bagels, pasta), your muscle store can increase by up to 2.5
times."
If you eat more carbohydrate than your muscles can store then
the rate of oxidation increases. In other words, your
body "turns up the heat" and burns carbohydrate faster. Only
when your body has filled all possible stores and turned up the
burners full blast can it begin converting some of the extra
carbohydrates into fat. And by this time, you would be eating
truly massive amounts of food.
"Results from clinical nutrition studies show that the
conversion of carbohydrate to fat in healthy people is minor,
compared to storage of dietary fat. You only convert
carbohydrate to fat if your body is deprived of fat, or if your
body needs extra fat, as it does in the third trimester of
pregnancy," says Smith.
What Should You Do?
"The evidence that counting grams of fat is the key to weight
control is well documented, there is a mechanism for the process
that makes sense, and the scientific literature supports it. The
evidence that counting calories is the way to go is
inconsistent, seldom corrected for the known influence of fat,
often flawed, and there is no mechanism to explain how those
excess calories contribute to weight (except for those from
fat), that is consistent with human biochemistry," says Smith.
It is very hard to overeat on high carbohydrate foods because
they are bulky and often contain a lot of water. If you are in
good health, have a normal metabolism, and exercise
regularly, "Eat one gram of fat for each kilogram (2.2 pounds)
of body weight [or target body weight]," suggests Jack Daniels,
Ph.D., exercise physiologist and coach at Arizona State
University.
"It's never fun to cut out your favorite foods to lose weight.
That's why so many diets fail," says Kalish. "The best way to
lose weight and keep it off is to cut the fatty foods in your
diet. Select the low-fat alternatives when you can. And load up
on fresh fruits, vegetables, breads and pastas (without high-fat
spreads or sauces). You really can eat until you're full--if you
eat low-fat."